Skip to main content

Creativity in the Kitchen: Kitchen Sink Cookies

Scenario: Wild Thing wants to make cookies. Sounds good to me, so I say yes and get things prepped. With an excited toddler, I discover...WE HAVE NO SUGAR!! (Well, okay, we have less than 1/8 of a cup of sugar). I am fond of utilizing honey, maple syrup or agave nectar in recipes. But, WE HAVE NO MAPLE SYRUP (or agave nectar) and only about 1/2 cup of honey. Yikes. I survey the pantry and fridge and discover that we do have: overly ripe bananas, apricot jam, some trail mix, unsulphered molasses and yogurt.

Here's the resulting ingredient list for our creative kitchen sink cookies:
  • 1 cup oats
  • 1 cup flour
  • 1 large egg
  • 1/2 cup butter (melted)
  • 1/4 cup honey
  • 1/4 cup apricot jam
  • 1/4 cup molasses (maybe a little less, it's a strong flavor)
  • 1/4 cup yogurt
  • 1 mashed banana
  • the last of the sugar (maybe an 1/8 of a cup)
  • the last of the trail mix (maybe 1/4 of a cup)
  • 1/2 tsp baking soda
  • however much cinnamon Wild Thing shakes in
  • 1/4 tsp salt 
In a large bowl, we mixed the sweeteners, butter and egg-mixing well since we've got yogurt, banana and jam to incorporate throughout the batter. In a small bowl, we mixed the oats, flour, baking soda, salt, and cinnamon. Then, we dumped the dry ingredients from the small bowl into the large bowl with our "kitchen sink" concoction of sweeteners and Wild Thing also dumps in the trail mix we have left (so we get a few raisins and M&Ms in there).

We scooped the cookies onto 2 cookie sheets and put them in the oven (preheated to 350 degrees) for about 12-15 minutes. (I think - I just kept peeking on them). The cookies came out fine - in some ways they seemed a bit like muffins that were shaped like cookies, but they were good. 

Most importantly, Wild Thing had so much fun making them! So, don't let a missing ingredient get in your way, just get creative. You might end up making a healthier cookie!  

*I also think it could be fun to do an experiment with older kids in which you use different types of sweeteners and have a taste test! (You could have a honey batch, maple syrup batch, etc.) 

You might also like:
Toddler Games That Only Require You!
Learning Letters


  1. I love the name of this - "Kitchen Sink Cookies" - hehe. So creative and so cute ;) It sounds so delicious and fairly healthy, too!! Will have to try this for sure <3

    thanks for linking up to First Day of My Life's Tasty Tuesday :)

  2. Oh, thanks for suggesting these for my Mama bucket list! My little guy will love these! Pinning for later. :)

  3. How very zero waste :)

  4. Love how you just threw everything together - bet they were tasty and you didn't miss the sugar, and your son looks like he had a total blast! Thanks for sharing at the Kids Co-op :-)


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Happy Very Hungry Caterpillar Day: Celebrating 45 Years with Caterpillar and Butterfly Crafts from The Kid's Co-Op

March 20th is Very Hungry Caterpillar Day with celebrations and programs being held around the world to honor the 45th Anniversary of the book. 

We love The Very Hungry Caterpillar, so of course we're joining the fun. Plus, my youngest son's blog nickname is Caterpillar, after the book. Just as Wild Thing is my 4 year-old's nickname inspired by Where the Wild Things Are. 

Today, we'll be doing another Very Hungry Caterpillar Food Drive. We did our first one for Eric Carle's birthday last June and called it a Very Hungry Caterpillar Virtual Food Drive and loved hearing that the virtual part worked, as others were inspired by our online shares and also did VHC-inspired food drives.

P.S. The Very Hungry Caterpillar Virtual Food Drive post 
also features 40+ Activities Inspired by the Book, so you'll definitely want to check it out.
For our VHC-inspired food drive this time, Wild Thing will be helping me write the grocery list for food items to donate as we read the boo…

{A Season of Giving} 12 Days of Christmas: Celebrating through Giving

Stacy (the Great) of Kids Stuff World brought to my attention the 31 Days of Service/Giving Calender (and great e-book) from Mom It Forward. 

Having gotten to know Stacy really well through our joint Moms Fighting Hunger effort during Hunger Action Month, I was all too happen to jump on board and take on 12 Days of Christmas, the action prompt for Dec. 4th.

The e-book describes the prompt in this way:
Choose another family in your area to be the recipient of 12 days of gift giving. Try to think of a family that may be struggling financially, emotionally, or with health problems and might need a boost during the holiday season.E ach day, starting December 13, leave a gift anonymously on the doorstep of your chosen family. Involve the kiddos in your secret acts of service. Your gifts can relate to the “12 Days of Christmas” song verses (i.e. partridge in a pear tree, turtle doves, French hens, etc.) but it’s not necessary. Try to choose or provide handmade gifts, drawings or tre…

Happy Birthday, Eric Carle~We're Doing a Very Hungry Caterpillar Virtual Food Drive to Help Very Hungry Kids! Join Us!!

Summer is officially here (for half of the world anyway). For many of us, school was out well before the First Day of Summer/Summer Solstice on June 21st. While summer means beaches, pools and vacation for many families, it also means increased food insecurity for others. Food budgets increase for almost everyone in the summer, and families that rely on free and reduced school lunches struggle with the loss of these much needed meals (many schools also provide breakfast to children as well and for many children, their only meals are the ones they eat at school). For some reason, thoughts of the summer struggle against hunger surged to the forefront of my brain every time I read The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle, or overheard Wild Thing reading it to himself or his father or brother (he has the whole book memorized). 

Finally, it came together, that caterpillar who is so very hungry and needs all of those food items in order to become a beautiful butterfly made me think of all o…